Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig have married in a ceremony in New Jersey, sources confirmed Sunday — and the timing has given entertainment media one of its most satisfying symmetries of the year. The nuptials come just weeks after Shue's ex-wife Amy Robach and Fiebig's ex-husband T.J. Holmes, whose 2022 affair ended both their marriages, announced their own wedding plans.
Source: Page Six
A Remarkable Turn of Events
The story of these four people has been one of the most-followed celebrity relationship sagas of recent years. In late 2022, news broke that ABC News anchors Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes had been conducting an affair during the final year of their respective marriages — Robach to actor and former soccer player Andrew Shue, Holmes to attorney Marilee Fiebig. Both couples divorced in 2023. Holmes and Robach went public with their relationship and have been together since.
What wasn't widely expected was what happened next: Shue and Fiebig, who had both been described as the wronged parties in the situation, eventually found each other. Their relationship, first reported in late 2025, was initially kept very private. Their New Jersey wedding this weekend is the first major public milestone in a story that has captivated tabloid readers since 2022.
About the Couple
Andrew Shue, 57, is best known for his role as Billy Campbell in the hit 1990s drama Melrose Place. Since leaving acting, he has been involved in various business ventures, including co-founding the social networking site Do Something and focusing on family and philanthropy. He and Amy Robach were married for 12 years and have children together.
Marilee Fiebig is an attorney based in New York. She and T.J. Holmes married in 2010 and have one daughter together. Following the divorce, Fiebig largely stayed out of the public eye — her relationship with Shue, when it became known, was one she had clearly chosen to keep on her own terms.
The Wider Story
The Holmes-Robach affair and its aftermath became a genuine tabloid phenomenon partly because of the unusual symmetry: both people caught in the affair were high-profile television figures, and both their spouses found themselves at the center of an enormous media story they hadn't asked for. The fact that Shue and Fiebig have now, apparently, found happiness together — and that all four parties appear to be moving forward — gives the saga an ending that feels, against all odds, like something approaching resolution.
Friends of both Shue and Fiebig describe them as genuinely happy and well-matched. The New Jersey ceremony was small and private, attended only by close family. Neither party has commented publicly, and their representatives have not issued a statement.
